Burger Wars: In-N-Out vs. Five Guys

By Henry Lewis | WDSD Restaurant Reporter


The East Coast vs. West Coast rivalry is heating up again, and this time it smells delicious.  Since migrating westward into the Golden State, Five Guys Burger and Fries has been aggressively expanding its market, causing speculation over the effect it will have on California native, In-N-Out Burger.

The Los Angeles Times wrote last week that one In-N-Out customer passed up her longtime favorite burger joint for Five Guys. "We chose this over In-N-Out," she said, noting that she liked the East Coast chain's fresh, flavorful burgers and hand-cut fries.

Recently, Five Guys burgers beat In-N-Out on Zagat's 2010 Fast Food Survey, and restaurant industry analyst Steve West said, "They will definitely be a competitor to In-N-Out. The prices are comparable and the product is comparable." And though Five Guys doesn't offer drive-thru service, they do make up for it with free peanuts! West said, "They're going to probably take market share from In-N-Out. Will they supplant In-N-Out? I don't think so....In-N-Out is so cultish in Southern California, it's going to be hard to break that habit."

As for the competition coming into their backyard, In-N-Out isn't planning to make any changes. "We've been focusing on the same thing for 62 years," Executive Vice President Carl Van Fleet told the newspaper. "Freshness, quality and cleanliness in our restaurants. We're just going to continue doing what we do."

With new and unique burger joint popping up all over the place (Fatburger, Smashburger, etc.), especially in San Diego, there may be more for these two burger chains to worry about than each other.  So chime in, and let us know where you stand on the ongoing burger wars. 


Read the LA Times Story here.

Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit!! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP

Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites


+4 #3 Andrew 2012-07-14 12:45
Coming from Calgary, Alberta. I've had both 5 guys and In-N-Out. 5 guys is good, but In-N-Out is where its at.

I can see why people like 5 guys, it really is good food.

Animal style wins me over though, hmmmm.
+3 #2 Travelling Bartender 2012-01-07 08:22
Five Guys cost a bit more than In-n-out, but the quality is there in spades. hand cut fries, and ALL ingredients prepared fresh daily.

Five Guys locations have no freezers on the premises, so everything is guaranteed to be as fresh as possible...!

I don't need a tattoo on my leg to tell me which one will taste better...!
+2 #1 Jon 2011-12-06 18:01
LOL! Saying that the prices are comparable is hilarious... five guys is nearly DOUBLE the price, what 12 bucks for a burger fries and a drink? They wont be gettin' a dime from me thats for sure.

Not to mention I have never tasted a thing as amazing as IN N OUT, I have the tattoo on my leg to prove it. :|

Add comment

Security code


We cover great San Diego County restaurants large and small -- from tasty taco stands to fancy fine dining palaces. If you would like to have one of our fearless reporters cover a favorite dining spot or food and wine event shoot us a short e-mail. or call 619 315 6074


Trey Foshee's Favorite San Diego Restaurants

in Media Watch
BY REBECCA FLINT MARX | Food & Wine Magazine   Trey Foshee, the executive chef and partner at George's at the Cove on the water in La Jolla, California, and an F&W Best New Chef 1998, has lived in San Diego for more than a decade. Here, he tells us where he likes to eat and drink when he's off duty, and why the city is as great for food (especially tacos) as it is for catching waves. READ MORE

Jamie Oliver: '30,000 napkins a month' stolen from restaurants

in Media Watch
It's not just table linen that's going missing, either - even the toilet flushers have been vanishing. Have you ever liberated a little memento from a restaurant?   From The Guardian   You might think that, along with fish forks, silver chargers and butlers, the demand for napkins would have dropped considerably over the past century. But you'd be wrong. Jamie Oliver is today complaining that each month 30,000 napkins are pinched from his restaurants.   This is a staggering number. And it's not just the napkins. Oliver had installed Thomas Crapper toilets on account of them looking "wicked", but since the flushers started going walkies he's had to weld them on. READ MORE


in Media Watch
Love them or fear them, here's an ironic round-up of some of the world's foulest, tastiest - and yes, stinkiest - cheese varieties   BY JAMES BRENNAN | Fine Dining Lovers   Some are banned from public transport, while others could awaken the dead, but smelly cheese is loved by many for its nutty, buttery and often mild flavour. The smelliest are often white, soft washed-rind cheeses, which are brushed with liquids or smeared with bacteria as they ripen. The foul-smelling organism that makes them reek like a cesspool is called brevibacterium linens, which also causes foot-odour in humans.   Love them or fear them, here's a round-up of some of the world's foulest. READ MORE

SF Restaurants Scam Employee Healthcare Ordinance

in Media Watch
S.F. civil grand jury slams restaurant health care surcharges     By Barbara Grady | SF Public Press   UPDATED 6:53 p.m. with response from the mayor.   San Francisco's civil grand jury on Thursday chastised many of the city's restaurants for profiting from surcharges they add to customers' bills under the name of paying for health care and recommended that the city ban the practice. READ MORE

Noisy Restaurants; taking the Din Out of Dinner

in Media Watch
High noise levels have become an issue for more diners of late, and restaurants are heeding the clamor for some quiet.   By Tiffany Hsu, Los Angeles Times   Los Angele -- You can count on the hippest restaurants to have dazzling menus, stylish servers and an attractive clientele. And increasingly, there's a featured side dish: noise.   As restaurateurs strive to attract a younger crowd, they've ditched the pile carpets, soft tablecloths and plush velvet booths for crowded communal tables, clattering open kitchens and pounding Rihanna music. And it's all amplified by cavernous ceilings, spartan walls and bare floors. READ MORE

Waddling Into the Sunset

in Media Watch
California Chefs Mount a Repeal of Foie Gras Ban Set for July 1   By JESSE McKINLEY | New York Times   THE countdown to foie-mageddon has begun.   With less than a month until California's first-in-the nation ban on foie gras takes effect, fans of the fattened duck and goose liver are buying out stocks of the delicacy, searching for legal loopholes and sating themselves at a series of foie-heavy goodbyes. READ MORE

Hotel La Jolla Renovation Includes Addition of Cusp Dining & Drinks

in Media Watch
By Brandon Hernández |SD Reader   Kimpton's big renovation of Hotel La Jolla is in the midst of wrapping up. When complete, the building will house a new restaurant called Cusp Dining & Drinks. The restaurant will takeover the space previously occupied by Clay's La Jolla, a spot that had good food but struggled to bring in clientele. Its replacement is reminiscent of how Saltbox supplanted the similarly challenged Suite and Tender at Hotel Palomar when Kimpton took over the downtown property last year. READ MORE

Cohn Restaurant Group's 100 Wines Opens in Hawaii

in Media Watch
Share Euro plates with friends as you sip wines at happening new Lahaina Gateway hot spot   By CARLA TRACY - Dining Editor |The Maui News   The Cohn Restaurant Group, based out of San Diego, has created a winner and a half with its latest Maui venture.   In fact, I can't wait to get back there again to sip a nice Italian Sangiovese and dive into perfectly ripe and room-t emperature cheeses such as Saint Andre.   READ MORE


By 2g1c2 girls 1 cup

By 2g1c2 girls 1 cup

By 2g1c2 girls 1 cup